Tears began to flow down the faces of coach Kevin Borseth’s wife and daughter even before they filled up in his own eyes and eventually those of his Green Bay players.
After breaking a five-year NCAA Tournament dry spell by winning the Horizon League postseason title, the emotions overflowed. During Sunday’s selection show, Green Bay’s players were cheering for television cameras with a message from their well-established program to the rest of the college basketball world.
The Phoenix are back and they’re on the rise once again.
“He (Borseth) has won it several times, but I saw him crying before the game,” said guard Cassie Schiltz, her voice starting to crack. “To be able to do this with him, it means so much. He cares about us as players, but he cares about more us as people, and he values family. So to do it all together with our families, it’s just awesome.”
By the time Schiltz finished, Borseth and tourney MVP Natalie McNeal were wiping their eyes, too.
Perhaps no Green Bay player understood the full significance of what last week’s 64-40 victory meant better than Schiltz, who grew up in the 2,500-person enclave of Luxemburg, Wisconsin, 17 miles east of Green Bay.
She was a fan of the Phoenix (27-6) during that 22-year span when they made 18 NCAA tourney appearances. She dreamed of playing for Borseth, who won 216 games in his first nine seasons in Green Bay and 294 in the dozen seasons since returning to Green Bay after five seasons at Michigan.
And she endured the pain of three straight conference tourney losses to Cleveland State, including a bitter 73-61 loss in the 2023 championship game — a loss that extended Green Bay’s drought.
This time, Schiltz and her teammates made sure it was no contest.
Means finished with 32 points and eight rebounds while going 15 of 21 from the field. Schiltz added eight points, six rebounds and five assists before, finally, posing with the league’s coveted “punched ticket” placard.
“You know we ended their season the last three years and there’s no doubt they showed up and said It’s not going to happen again,” Cleveland State coach Chris Kielsmeier said. “They really came after us, their players were ready to play, and they did not want to experience some of the frustrations they’ve experienced in the past.”
For the 69-year-old Borseth, whose career has been filled with joyous moments, excruciating disappointments, one unforgettable postgame rant and a pure love of family, it will go down as one of his most cherished memories — even if he didn’t see everything.
While Green Bay’s players repeatedly chased down loose balls, the two freshmen from Minnesota, Maren Westin and Sophie Lahti, were doing a do-si-do on the bench.
And when Borseth yelled for players to “hunt their opportunity” between the third and fourth quarters, they obeyed. The fans responded in kind, chanting M-V-P as McNeal made her final free throws and sharing a hug with Borseth when he took her out.
“It’s just enjoying every moment as they come and like coach said, I came to Green Bay with hopes of being on a winning team like this,” McNeal said. “So it’s really rewarding to have teammates like Cassie and coach Borseth up here that made this dream a reality.”
The 11th-seeded Phoenix are going to Raleigh, North Carolina, on Saturday to play against sixth-seeded Tennessee (19-12), a team trying to regain its previous status. If they win against the Volunteers, who have a 5-4 record over their last nine SEC games, they could then face third-seeded North Carolina State.
Between 2003 and 2012, Green Bay made it to the second round five times, including its first two trips with Borseth as head coach. They also won a first-round WNIT game against Niagara last year.
Borseth said, "It's been a long time since we've been there and it feels like the first time, you know someone had that song. I don't know the saying, but it feels like the first time, it really does. I’m thrilled for the players on this team."
The question is whether Green Bay can recreate the emotional scene that happened in Indianapolis, with Borseth embracing his teary-eyed wife and daughter on the court and then leading fans and the pep band in chants of ‘We are, Green Bay.’
Even if the tears start flowing for a different reason on Saturday, these 13 players, 12 of whom could be back next season, know they and Borseth achieved one goal by bringing the Phoenix back into the national spotlight.
Schiltz said, “I grew up near Green Bay and attended all the games, and it was my dream to get to the NCAA Tournament. It took a few years, but we did it. We had a couple alumni in the stands who traveled to Indianapolis just to watch because of this man right here. He’s a great coach and person, and it’s so fulfilling to play for him.”
