In 22-year-old Anthony Volpe, the New York Yankees have hope for a long-term, franchise shortstop.
After choosing Volpe as the 30th pick in the 2019 draft, he became the team’s everyday shortstop last season with a one-year, $720,000 contract in addition to a $2.7 million signing bonus. He's set to earn another $720,000 deal, but if he becomes the player that many expect, he’ll soon ask for more money from the Yankees.
He will enter his first year of arbitration in 2026, and The Athletic’s Tim Britton projected he will eventually demand a deal in the range of $104 million over nine years. But Britton also recommended that “both sides should hold off.”
The Yankees have the financial capability to assess Volpe's potential before committing to a large contract, especially after a promising rookie season.
With Anthony Volpe, the New York Yankees Could Have Future Franchise Shortstop
Volpe’s debut season showed strong defensive skills, but he needs to improve on the offensive side.
In 2023, Volpe became the first rookie in franchise history to earn a Gold Glove Award, slashing .209/.283/.383 with 21 homers and 24 swiped bags in 541 at bats. If he can bring his performance at the plate up to par with his defense, the Yankees could have a fitting heir to long-time shortstop/captain Derek Jeter. And there’s reason to hope for improvement in 2024.
“Volpe went to the laboratory in the offseason, beginning workouts at the Yankees minor league facility in early January,” Joel Sherman reported for the New York Post. “New hitting coach James Rowson said Volpe is ‘not working as uphill as he was and is working more through the ball.’ Rowson believes that will decrease the holes in his swing, which combined with Volpe’s strong concept of the strike zone should lead to more walks and more opportunities to use his legs.”
The changes seem to be making an impact thus far in Spring Training. In 38 pre-season at bats, Volpe has a .368 average and a .915 OPS.
“As he approaches his second year as a big league shortstop, Volpe says he is spending his spring focusing on deleting an uppercut from his swing, aiming to do damage on high heat more frequently,” MLB.com reported.
The New York Yankees Lack Option at Shortstop
The Yankees are counting on big things from Volpe, not just well into the future, but to bolster their 2024 aspirations of returning to the World Series.
Volpe projects to bat at the tail end of a potent Yankees order, but their depth at shortstop would be a concern without him.
Oswald Peraza currently projects to be the go-to substitute for Volpe if needed. But Peraza was shut down with shoulder problems that are expected to persist into the season. The next option could be 25-year-old Oswaldo Cabrera, but that’s far from certain as well.
“Without Peraza, utility man Oswaldo Cabrera could serve as the backup shortstop, but he may be needed to bounce around the entire field — and still has to prove he can hit major league pitching,” Mark W. Sanchez reported for the Post. “He keeps doing well defensively, and (manager Aaron) Boone trusts him in any position, even at shortstop, but his performance in early spring games has not been good.”
So, there are several reasons why Volpe looks like the future shortstop for the Yankees, as long as he can improve his approach when batting. If he does, the team will likely have to pay a lot to keep him.
