The Houston Astros have been one of MLB’s biggest disappointments to start the 2024 season. Their 12-23 record before games began on May 8 has them in last place in the American League West. But could they turn things around and become trade-deadline buyers? And would they make a run at Toronto Blue Jays first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr.?
Jim Bowden of The Athletic would like to see it happen. He proposed the following hypothetical trade between Houston and Toronto in a May 6 article:
- Astros would get first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
- Blue Jays would get first baseman/outfielder Joey Loperfido and outfielder Kenedy Corona
“Guerrero will be a free agent after the 2025 season and the Blue Jays have yet to sign him to a long-term deal. They’d get a much better return in a trade now than they would in the offseason or in the leadup to next year’s trade deadline; therefore, they’ll need to seriously consider dealing him this July if they fall out of the race,” Bowden said. “Guerrero is still only 25 years old and just entering his prime years. Could you imagine him hitting between Yordan Alvarez and Kyle Tucker over the next two seasons (at least)?”
According to MLB.com, Loperfido (sixth) and Corona (12th) are top 15 prospects in the Astros’ system. Loperfido recently made his MLB debut for Houston and Corona is currently in Double-A.
How Would Guerrero-to-Houston Actually Work?
At first glance, Houston going after Guerrero might not make much sense. After all, the Astros have first baseman Jose Abreu under contract through the end of 2025. However, his production has been nonexistent amid the club’s awful start.
His first 77 plate appearances of 2024 have led to a .059/.156/.113 triple slash. It includes just one extra-base hit (a double), a -20 wRC+ and -1.2 fWAR. Abreu’s first year in Houston wasn’t terrific, either. His counting stats looked decent (18 home runs, 90 RBI and 62 runs scored), but it was still accompanied by a .237/.296/.383 line, a 86 wRC+ and -0.5 fWAR.
He agreed to be optioned to the minors on April 30 to work through this deep slump and get his timing back. But what if it doesn’t work and the Astros need to acquire some power on the trade market?
That’s where Guerrero could come into play. Toronto likely isn’t ready to declare itself a seller, but they’re another team off to a rough start. The Jays entered action on May 8 with a 17-20 record while residing in the AL East basement.
Guerrero has also underachieved based on his early-season performance. His first 158 plate appearances have yielded a .234/.335/.365 line with four home runs and 15 RBI. Those numbers aren’t great, but they’d be a drastic improvement over Abreu. Especially if the current combination of Loperfido and Jon Singleton isn’t cutting it from a production standpoint.
Are the Astros Thinking About Selling at the Deadline?
Even with a rough start, the beginning of May typically isn’t the time to surrender on a season. While it was true for the Miami Marlins, the Astros entered 2024 with different expectations.
They have made it to the American League Championship Series for seven consecutive years, and have won two World Series titles. The MLB's expanded postseason field also allows struggling teams to stay competitive after the All-Star break.
Will the Astros sell players before the July 30 trade deadline? Houston general manager Dana Brown is not considering that possibility seriously at this time.
“I don’t see any chance of us becoming sellers. I think the team is too good,” Brown stated during an appearance on MLB Network’s MLB Now on May 7. on MLB Network’s MLB Now. “If players start performing better, positive outcomes will follow.”
Despite Houston's reluctance to give up, this question will persist until the team improves.
